top of page
  • Good Morning Liberty

Debunking Tucker Carlson's Myth of America's Libertarian Economy

Given the constant failures of government intervention in our economy, it's not uncommon to encounter the claim that the United States operates under a libertarian economy. This assertion is clearly a myth, not a reality.


That didn't stop Tucker Carlson from blaming America's woes on "Libertarian Economics" in a recent appearance on Glenn Greenwald's "System Update."




Understanding Libertarianism

At its core, libertarianism advocates for minimal government intervention in personal and economic affairs. A true libertarian economy would be characterized by free-market capitalism, minimal regulations, low taxes, and a limited role for the government in business operations.


Check out these famous quotes from Libertarian thinkers in contrast with the current state of the American economy:


1.Milton Friedman: "The great advances of civilization, whether in architecture or painting, in science or literature, in industry or agriculture, have never come from centralized government."


Friedman, a Nobel Prize-winning economist, was known for his strong belief in free-market capitalism and minimal government intervention.


2. Friedrich Hayek: "The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design."


Hayek, another Nobel laureate, was a prominent figure in the development of libertarian economic theories and a strong critic of socialism and central planning.


3. Ayn Rand: "The question isn’t who is going to let me; it’s who is going to stop me."

While not an economist, Ayn Rand's philosophy of Objectivism has greatly influenced libertarian thought, emphasizing individual rights and self-interest.


4. Ludwig von Mises: "Government is the negation of liberty."


Von Mises, a key figure in the Austrian School of economics, advocated for a laissez-faire approach to economics and was a staunch critic of socialism.


5. Ron Paul: "One thing is clear: The Founding Fathers never intended a nation where citizens would pay nearly half of everything they earn to the government."


Ron Paul, a former U.S. Congressman and presidential candidate, is known for his libertarian stance, advocating for a smaller government and greater personal freedoms.


While the U.S. economy does embrace some elements of capitalism, it's far from the libertarian ideal. Here are key areas where the U.S. diverges significantly from a libertarian model:


Government Regulation:

The U.S. has a complex system of regulations affecting all sectors, from finance to health care. These regulations are implemented to protect consumers, the environment, and to ensure fair competition. Such regulatory frameworks are contrary to the libertarian ethos of minimal government intervention.


In the United States, businesses face a myriad of regulatory hurdles that can vary greatly depending on the industry, size of the company, and location. One major area of regulation is compliance with federal and state tax laws, which involves accurate record-keeping, regular filings, and navigating complex tax codes. Businesses in certain sectors, like healthcare or finance, face additional layers of scrutiny; for example, healthcare providers must comply with HIPAA for patient privacy, and financial institutions are subject to regulations like the Dodd-Frank Act for financial practices and consumer protection. Environmental regulations, such as those enforced by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), also pose significant compliance requirements for businesses in manufacturing, energy, and other industries. These regulations aim to protect the environment but often require businesses to invest in cleaner technologies and maintain rigorous reporting on their environmental impact.


Another major area of regulatory complexity is labor laws, encompassing a range of issues from minimum wage standards to workplace safety, governed by agencies like the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). Compliance with these regulations requires businesses to maintain safe working conditions, provide fair wages, and often keep detailed records of their employment practices. Additionally, for businesses looking to expand or merge, antitrust laws ensure that competition remains fair and markets are not monopolized. Navigating the bureaucracy of permits and licenses, especially for new businesses or those expanding into new locations or markets, adds another layer of complexity. These regulatory challenges not only demand resources for compliance but also require businesses to stay continually informed about evolving laws and regulations, which can be especially burdensome for small businesses with limited resources.


Taxation:

Libertarianism advocates for low taxes, yet the U.S. has a progressive tax system where individuals and corporations are subjected to multiple layers of taxation.


Americans are subject to a variety of taxes, each with its own set of rules and purposes. One of the most well-known is the federal income tax. This is a progressive tax, meaning the rate increases as an individual's or a household's income increases. Tax brackets are adjusted periodically to account for inflation. Besides the federal income tax, many states and some local governments also impose their own income taxes with rates and rules varying significantly across different regions. Additionally, the U.S. imposes payroll taxes, which are used to fund Social Security and Medicare. These are split between employers and employees, with self-employed individuals paying the full rate.


Other significant taxes include sales taxes, applied to the purchase of goods and services. While the federal government does not impose a national sales tax, most states and some local jurisdictions do. The rates and items subject to sales tax can vary widely. Property taxes, primarily levied by local governments, are another major source of revenue, based on the value of real estate and, in some cases, personal property like vehicles. Capital gains taxes apply to profits from the sale of assets like stocks or real estate, with rates depending on the length of time the asset was held and the taxpayer's income level. Lastly, there are various other taxes like estate taxes, excise taxes on specific goods like alcohol and tobacco, and tariffs or duties on imported goods, each playing a role in the complex tapestry of the American tax system.


Social Welfare Programs:

The existence of social welfare programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid is another aspect that contradicts libertarian principles. These programs, funded by taxpayer money, represent a significant government role in providing social safety nets.


The United States offers a variety of social welfare programs designed to assist individuals and families in need, each targeting specific areas of support. One of the most well-known is Social Security, a federal program providing retirement, disability, and survivors benefits, primarily funded through payroll taxes. Another significant program is Medicare, a federal health insurance program mainly for people aged 65 and older, but also for younger individuals with certain disabilities or diseases. Medicaid, jointly funded by the federal and state governments, offers health coverage to low-income individuals and families, including eligible elderly adults, people with disabilities, pregnant women, and children. The Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) extends health coverage to children in families with incomes too high to qualify for Medicaid but too low to afford private insurance.


In addition to healthcare-related benefits, the U.S. has several programs aimed at reducing poverty and providing food security. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly known as food stamps, helps low-income individuals and families afford food. The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program provides temporary financial assistance and support services to families with children. Housing assistance, administered by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), includes various programs like Section 8 housing vouchers, which help low-income tenants afford rent in the private market. There are also unemployment insurance benefits, providing temporary income to eligible workers who have lost their jobs. These programs, along with others like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Supplemental Security Income (SSI), form the backbone of the social safety net in the United States, aiming to provide a minimum level of support to vulnerable populations.



Monetary Policy:

The Federal Reserve plays a crucial role in the U.S. economy, controlling monetary policy, interest rates, and inflation. This central banking system is at odds with libertarian views that advocate for a laissez-faire approach to the economy.


Corporate Subsidies and Bailouts:

The U.S. government has a history of providing bailouts and subsidies to corporations, especially in sectors deemed vital for the national economy. This is contrary to the libertarian belief in free-market competition without government aid.


The Misconception


The misconception that the U.S. has a libertarian economy likely stems from its strong capitalist foundation and the cultural value placed on individualism and entrepreneurial spirit. However, the presence of government involvement at multiple levels clearly indicates that the U.S. operates under a mixed economic model.


While the United States certainly values some principles that align with libertarianism, such as individual freedom and a market-based economy, it is far from a libertarian utopia. The blend of government regulations, taxation, social welfare programs, and a central banking system all point to a planned economy.

Comments


bottom of page